“Actors are by nature volatile- alchemic creatures composed of incendiary elements, emotion and ego and envy. Heat them up, stir them together and sometimes you get gold. Sometimes disaster.”
If We Were Villains is an impressive debut novel by author M.L. Rio. Set against the atmospheric backdrop of an exclusive arts school, it explores the complex relationships between a group of seven students in the drama department. Did I mention that these students live and breathe the Bard? This quirky institution for higher learning only stages Shakespearean productions.
The story begins with our main character, Oliver, in shackles. He is finally ready to confess what actually transpired at Dellecher University. I’d like to reveal more about the plot, but since this is a mystery it’s better you go in blind.
This is easily one of the best novels I read in 2018. Rio’s writing is lyrical and mesmerizing, drawing the reader into her lurid tale. The characterization is also striking. It may seem daunting to keep track of seven central characters, but Rio makes it feel like a privilege. I enjoyed getting to know each and every one of them intimately. However, I do wish that two members of the group, the elusive Filipa and timid Wren, were developed more fully; they had great potential.
Usually when a book has excellent character development the plot has a tendency to suffer, but that isn’t the case here. If We Were Villains is incredibly balanced and the mystery is just as compelling as the players. Let’s just say I was genuinely surprised to discover who was responsible for a certain unfortunate incident. It is also worth mentioning that the ending is dramatic, some may argue exceedingly so. But isn’t this a novel about theatrics, after all?
If We Were Villains will invariably be compared to Donna Tarrt’s novel, The Secret History. While I will admit that there are many similar elements, I still feel that the former stands on its own and if anything could be considered an homage to Tarrt’s beloved book. I am willing to face some potential backlash here and go as far as to say that I actually prefer If We Were Villains… I know, utter blasphemy. I think Rio’s novel has the upper hand with its superior pacing and likable characters. Both works certainly have their own unique merits and I encourage you to read both if you haven’t already.
In conclusion, I highly recommend If We Were Villains. Readers who enjoy riveting psychological thrillers with a pinch of higher education and a sprinkle of Shakespeare will be smitten.
